Why some US families abroad hesitate to document their children’s U.S. citizenship, and why simplifying tax compliance matters.
I saw a post on Twitter (okay, aka X) last night about dual U.S. citizens being required to bring their minor U.S. citizen children into the USA with a U.S. passport. I shared it with my own comments, the the responses are enlightening.
Now, let’s be clear. A U.S. citizen is generally required to leave the USA and enter the USA on their U.S. passport, subject to limited exceptions. This has been the requirement for as long as I’ve known about it. Have some people skated past this requirement in the past, especially for their minor children? Probably, but that doesn’t mean the requirement didn’t apply.
Having recently received recognition of my Italian citizenship, I have done the research and learned those requirements so I can follow them.
When a Passport Discussion Turns into a Tax Discussion
But here’s the interesting thing. The comments to my share and on the original post quickly drift away from immigration and travel issues into the heart of the matter for US citizens living outside the USA – TAXES.
The USA is one of the few countries that taxes its citizens on their worldwide income, regardless of where the citizen resides and earns the money. Over the past couple of decades, the U.S. government has gotten a lot stricter and significantly increased the foreign financial reporting requirements, primarily to combat offshore tax evasion and improve transparency. But these requirements also affect ordinary U.S. citizens living abroad in addition to the taxpayers engaged in offshore tax evasion.
We can debate all we want about whether U.S. citizens abroad should be taxed on their worldwide income, and I think there are persuasive arguments on both sides of the debate.
What’s more nuanced and technical, is given the current system, how can we make it easier to comply with the foreign income reporting, foreign bank account and investment reporting, and applying tax treaties into the everyday life of U.S. citizens living abroad?
Why Some Parents Hesitate to Document Their Children’s U.S. Citizenship
The comments around this post on X really focused on the assumption that dual U.S. citizens abroad are avoiding getting their minor children U.S. passports to keep the children out of the cross-hairs of the U.S. government, and by extension, the IRS. If the kids aren’t documented, perhaps they can stay off the radar until they grow up and can decide if they want to enter the U.S. system (i.e., that US tax system). Of course, whether a child born abroad acquires U.S. citizenship depends on the applicable citizenship laws. Obtaining a U.S. passport generally documents that citizenship rather than creating it.
It’s definitely a nuanced argument, but it does make sense to me.
Again, let me put on my U.S. tax CPA hat – all US citizens are generally subject to tax on their worldwide income, and those who meet the applicable filing requirements must report that income to the IRS. It doesn’t matter if they have a USA passport or not. And even when no U.S. income tax is owed, separate financial reporting requirements may still apply.
But I realize that if the IRS doesn’t know the person exists, it may be less likely to identify their filing obligations unless something else brings them to its attention.
My primary stance is I can’t advise you to do anything other than follow the law. But the human side of me understands why this happens and why you might choose not to follow my advice.
We Need to Make Tax Compliance Easier
What I can argue for and totally support is simplifying the tax and financial reporting so this really isn’t an issue anymore.
I don’t want to read about Americans living abroad who are afraid of the ramifications of documenting their children as U.S. citizens because of the TAX COMPLIANCE complications.
That really breaks my heart.
And that’s why I think we need to have more conversations about this issue. In future posts, I plan to explore the U.S. income tax fling requirements for citizens living abroad, the foreign bank account and investing reporting requirements, and how these complications affect their everyday lives.
We should be encouraging Congress to make the law easier to follow and comply with.

